Excel, ERP, PunchOut or Marketplace: Which Tool to Choose?
- Alexandre Duquenoy
- Estimated reading time: 14 minutes
Your franchisees still order by Excel. Everyday purchases slip past your contracts. One store is out of stock while the store next door has the product. You are looking for a tool, and you are offered everything at once: an ERP module, a PunchOut connection, an e-procurement suite, a B2B portal or a marketplace.
These tools don’t solve the same problem. A PunchOut connects your purchasing software to a supplier’s website. An e-procurement suite organizes requests, approvals and invoices. A marketplace brings several suppliers together in a single catalog. Choosing the wrong family of tools costs more than choosing the wrong vendor.
So this article starts from the problem, in the words of the people who live it, and gives for each one the family of tools that solves it. It also says when Excel or your ERP is enough.
One problem, one tool: the table
Find the sentence that sounds like yours. The second column gives the family of tools and the third explains why.
| What you say | The tool that solves it | Why this one | Learn more |
|---|---|---|---|
| "We track our purchases in an Excel file, and it holds up." | Excel, as long as that is true | Few suppliers, few orders, a single person placing them: one more tool would cost more than it brings. | / |
| "Our franchisees still order by Excel or email." | Multi-supplier ordering portal | The head office publishes a catalog at negotiated prices, and each location orders on its own. | Centralizing network orders |
| "We want to digitize our purchasing group." | Multi-supplier marketplace | Members order from all listed suppliers in a single cart, and the group keeps control of supplier listing and discounts. | Group purchasing platform |
| "Our business customers order by email and phone." | Self-service B2B portal connected to the ERP | You are the only seller: customers find their prices, order and track deliveries without calling customer service. | / |
| "Our everyday purchases escape our contracts." | Internal multi-supplier purchasing catalog | Teams find the negotiated offering faster than anywhere else: buying off-contract no longer saves time. | Purchasing solution |
| "We mostly buy from three or four large suppliers who are already equipped." | PunchOut from your ERP or purchasing suite | Each supplier keeps its website and your contract prices, and the cart comes back to your tool for approval. | PunchOut explained |
| "Approvals and invoices take us weeks." | E-procurement suite (procure-to-pay) | The problem is the process (request, approval, purchase order, invoice matching), not the catalog. | Procure-to-pay: the guide |
| "Our suppliers send us PDF catalogs and Excel files." | Supplier portal | Each supplier updates its own products, prices and inventory, in the same format. | Supplier catalogs without a system |
| "One store is out of stock while another has the product." | Unified inventory and network selling | Inventory from every store is visible online, and each sale goes to the store that delivers. | Unified inventory |
| "We want to expand our catalog without tying up inventory." | Multi-vendor marketplace | Third-party sellers publish their products and ship them themselves, and you earn a commission. | FFT case study |
| "We want to offer partner services to our customers." | Services marketplace | Booking, pay-per-service and provider reviews in one place. | Create a services marketplace |
| "We have equipment sitting idle at our sites." | Internal reuse platform | Sites publish their surplus, and others pick it up before buying new. | Dormant and unsold stock |
| "Our custom-built platform costs too much to maintain." | SaaS marketplace solution | Hosting, maintenance and updates are shared across the vendor's customers. | Changing marketplace solution |
The six families of tools, and the limit of each
For C-class purchasing, this video compares these families of tools criterion by criterion, including ERP compatibility:
Excel and email
Free, already installed, understood by everyone. It is the right choice as long as one or two people place orders with a handful of suppliers.
Its limit: it is reached when several people edit the same file: versions multiply and errors go unnoticed.
The ERP purchasing or sales module
The ERP manages inventory, accounting and invoicing. It is the right tool for anything that has to be accurate to the cent.
Its limit: it isn’t designed for dozens of people, often outside the company, to order in it on their own. Instead, a portal, a PunchOut or a marketplace is connected to the ERP, which remains the system of record for inventory and invoices. To choose the ERP itself: our ERP comparison.
PunchOut
From your ERP or purchasing suite, the buyer opens the supplier’s website, fills a cart at your contract prices, and the cart then comes back to your tool for approval. It is the right choice with a few large suppliers who are already equipped.
Its limit: one connection and one cart per supplier. With thirty suppliers, the buyer jumps from one website to another and no longer compares anything.
The e-procurement suite
It organizes the purchasing process, from request to invoice: approval, purchase order, receipt, matching. It is the right choice when the problem is compliance or approval time.
Its limit: the offering is often thin. The suite relies on imported catalogs or PunchOut to display products. More details in our e-procurement guide. To compare vendors: our procurement software comparison.
The self-service B2B portal
You are the only seller. Your business customers find their prices, order and track deliveries without calling customer service. That is what they expect: 67% of B2B buyers prefer a rep-free buying experience, according to a Gartner survey of 646 buyers conducted in 2025.
Its limit: a single seller. If your customers also ask you for products you don’t make, the portal is no longer enough.
The marketplace
Several suppliers or sellers in the same catalog, with a single cart, prices by customer profile and commission calculation. It is used for buying (internal catalog, purchasing group, network orders) as well as selling (expanding your offering, selling online with your stores). It is the right choice as soon as the offering comes from several suppliers, or several locations need to order or sell together.
Its limit: a marketplace lives off its suppliers. You have to bring them on board and keep the catalog active, or the platform stays empty. That is the job of Origami Marketplace, which publishes this type of platform and supports this launch phase.
Need a sample specification document?
A ready-to-use template to quickly frame your multi-vendor or multi-supplier platform project, compare market solutions and secure your project.
PunchOut, e-procurement or marketplace: the difference
The three are often presented as competitors. Yet they answer different questions.
| Criterion | PunchOut | E-procurement suite | Marketplace |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A connection between your purchasing tool and a supplier's website | Software that manages the purchasing process, from request to invoice | A platform that brings several suppliers together in one catalog |
| Where the buyer searches | On each supplier's website | In imported catalogs or through PunchOut | In a single catalog, across all suppliers |
| Who keeps the catalog up to date | Each supplier, on its website | The purchasing team, which imports the files | Each supplier, on the platform |
| Cart | One per supplier | Depends on the product source | A single one for all suppliers |
| Best suited when | A few large suppliers who are already equipped | The bottleneck is the approval process and compliance | The offering comes from many suppliers, or many sites place orders |
They are often combined: a company keeps its e-procurement suite for approvals and connects a multi-supplier catalog to it. For details on how each works: PunchOut and the e-procurement marketplace.
Three questions to choose
- Who sells? Only you: a B2B portal is enough. Several suppliers or sellers: a PunchOut if they are few and already equipped, a marketplace beyond that.
- Who orders? A small purchasing team: an e-procurement suite or PunchOut. Hundreds of people or locations: a simple self-service catalog, or they will keep ordering by email.
- Where is the bottleneck? In the offering (finding the right product at the right price): a catalog. In the process (approvals, invoices): an e-procurement suite. In inventory (stockouts here, surplus there): unified inventory.
In every case, the ERP stays in place: the tool you choose connects to it for inventory, orders and invoices.
Four problems solved with a marketplace
Four Origami Marketplace customers, four different starting points:
| Customer | Starting problem | Tool | Published results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orpi | Purchasing for 1,350 agencies, scattered | Multi-supplier ordering portal | 90% of quotes converted into orders, 3 days from order to delivery, suppliers paid in 5 days, 3.5% of purchases offset by commissions |
| French Tennis Federation | A paper catalog for clubs | Multi-supplier marketplace | Business volume up from €910,000 in 2023 to €1.2M in 2024 (+32%), 10,000 SKUs versus 2,000 at launch |
| French Football Federation | A purchasing group to modernize | Migration to a marketplace | More than 12,000 affiliated clubs on the new platform, history migrated with no loss, no service interruption |
| Eurogolf | Independent stores with no shared online sales | Unified inventory and network selling | More than 30 stores brought together on one site, 100% of sales attributed to the stores |
Frequently asked questions
No. The ERP remains the system of record for inventory, accounting and invoices. The marketplace connects to it: it receives products and prices, and sends orders back.
PunchOut works with a few large suppliers who are already equipped: the buyer orders on their website from your purchasing tool. Beyond that, a marketplace brings all suppliers’ offerings together in a single catalog, with a single cart.
Yes. The suite keeps the approval process and invoice processing, and the marketplace brings the multi-supplier catalog. The two connect through PunchOut or an API.
When several people edit the same file, when the number of suppliers grows, or when you need to prove who ordered what and at what price.
A B2B portal if you sell your catalog alone. A marketplace if you want to add partners’ offerings, or sell online with your stores.
Conclusion: start from the problem, not the tool
An ERP, a PunchOut, an e-procurement suite, a B2B portal and a marketplace can coexist in the same company. Each one solves a specific problem. The right starting point is the sentence your teams keep repeating, not a feature list.
Tell us what you need
We’ll tell you which family of tools fits, even when it isn’t a marketplace.